Lesson Four - When Feelings Exceed Words

I found I could say things with color and shapes that I couldn't say any other way... things I had no words for.

– Georgia O’Keeffe

CREATIVE ACTIVITY - Photography Walk

Lesson Intention:

In her work supporting survivors of trauma with their creative writing, social science researcher Patti Lather borrowed the German poet Rilke’s term, the “Too Big” to describe those experiences that are so intense that they exceed words. She called these stories “Too Big Stories.”  Most people have experienced something in their lives that feels overwhelming because of the emotional size of it; the grief almost swallowed them whole, the fear was indescribable, the anger vibrated with energy but exceeded language. When young people are walking through immense heartbreak, or emotions like sadness or anger or loneliness, it is our role as teachers and counselors to witness that intensity with them. In addition, we want to be able to model methods for expressing that emotion without always using words to describe the feeling. In this activity, students are invited to explore emotions that feel too complex or large to put into words by using metaphor and photography. This will help students to speak to the experiences that feel unspeakable.

Social Emotional Learning Goals:

· Recognize that emotions are complex and transcend distinct labels.

· Understand the possibility of feeling more than one emotion at once.

 

Materials for Lesson:

In Preparation for Lesson:

Prior to teaching this lesson, watch the video (for this lesson, it is a combined guest artist/expert video) and take an example photograph to share with your students.  

Map out the route for the photography walk ahead of time. Your students will be taking this walk as they look for  images to represent the way they feel. 

Students will need to use the cameras on their cell phones for this lesson. If they do not have phones to use for this purpose, shared tablets can be good alternatives. Please make sure you know what your students’ technology needs are ahead of time. 

For a tech free option, you can supply your students with paper and pencil or pen, and they can draw the images they see.

Featured Video:

Dr. Neha Chaudhary explains that emotions are complex, that they can transcend labels and that it is possible to feel more than one emotion at the same time. She shares the way photography helps her represent complex emotions. 

Courtney Payton, photographer for the Cleveland Cavaliers, shares the way that photography has supported him in expressing emotions.

 

Additional Video:

Yikia Xu describes  his experience with loneliness as an immigrant in the United States and offers that taking photographs allows him to acknowledge and accept these emotions.

Lesson Plan:

Display the ‘welcome slide’ from the Lesson 4 PowerPoint as you begin.

*Slide 1

As discussed in the teacher training, remember to make the suggested language below authentic to yourself and meaningful for your students.

Launching the Lesson:

* Slide 2

  • Connect this lesson with the previous one by explaining that the previous lesson brought up some powerful emotions, and sometimes these emotions are so big that it is impossible to label them or put them into words. Reference the story you were thinking about while making the digital collage and share the feeling that came up that transcended a label – that was too hard to put into words – because it was so big and also because when you reflected on it, it was really more than one emotion at once.

    Example of What You Could Say:

    “In our previous lesson, we explored how creativity can offer a way for us to feel our difficult feelings. I know that when I was thinking about the experience I shared with you yesterday, when I talked about_______ (refers to the story you shared in your collage), the emotions felt complex for me. I found that I was feeling multiple emotions at once, and it’s not so easy to put those emotions into words. Have you ever had this experience where you can remember feeling more than one emotion at once or couldn’t label exactly how you were feeling?  This idea, the potential to feel multiple and contradictory feelings, is what we are going to explore together today.”

  • Explain that they will watch a mental health expert describe the complexity of emotions in a short video.

    Example of What You Could Say:
    “Let’s start with a video from a mental health expert who is also a photographer, and she will talk a little more about this idea of the complexity of emotions.”

Play Expert/Guest Artist Video:

The expert/guest artist describes the way photography can express complex emotions. She references the way metaphor can be useful in illustrating emotions without having to label them, sharing one of her photographs that serves as a metaphor for two conflicting feelings that she was experiencing when she took the photograph. 

Introducing the Guest Artist Video:

Connect the expert video to the guest artist video by noting their shared message- the importance of honoring complex emotions and the power of photography as a medium for emotional expression. The expert described the important role that photography can play in supporting people as they seek to represent complex emotions. The guest artist offers an additional illustration by explaining the way  photography helped him in his life. 

We have another short video that speaks to the way photography can help express emotions. This video is from the team photographer for the Cleveland Cavaliers. Listening to him talk about his photographs and seeing those images will provide an example of today’s activity.

Play Guest Artist Video:

The guest artist shares the way photography has supported him in representing emotions, and draws on his personal experience and artwork to illustrate this idea.

Introducing the Creative Activity:

  • At the conclusion of the expert/guest artist video, introduce the creative activity by explaining that the class will go outside on a group walk to take pictures of things that remind them of the way they feel. Students will look for an object that represents the way they feel in this moment, or the way they felt when they were having the experience, they described in their photo collage or “I could tell you…” poem. Once students find an object that is a metaphor for that feeling, they will take a picture of that object. They are welcome to take multiple pictures if they see more than one object that represents their feelings. Explain to students that when they return to the classroom, they will choose an image to display in a classroom art gallery. As always, students will have a choice about what they want to share with the class. Also, students can share their photographs anonymously. The photo walk will take approximately 15 minutes.

     

    Examples of What You Could Say:

     

    “In this video, the guest artist explained the way metaphors can represent feelings that are hard to put into words. Like this artist, we’re going to take photographs to illustrate complex feelings. For this activity, you might think back to one of the stories you’ve explored through art – the poem, the letter or the collage. You could also take a photograph that represents how you are feeling right now.  Maybe there will be an image that helps show the complexity of your emotions. Maybe you felt more than one emotion at once. Maybe there isn’t even a name for the emotion you felt. We are going to go outside and find something that represents one of those feelings. You can take a picture of it if you have a camera on your phone, or I have paper and pencils you can use to make a drawing. This is like a scavenger hunt without a list of what we are looking for.”

 

Creative Activity:

* Slide 3

Lead students outside on a group walk. This is not a scavenger hunt with hints or steps to check off, but a “hunt” in the sense that they are searching for images and items that resonate with them. These objects represent the way they feel right now or the way they felt in one of the stories they have written about already in this curriculum. Students will bring their cell phones if they have them or can share an iPad or polaroid camera to take their photographs.

Introducing the Wrap-up Activity:

  • Share a few images you took on the walk and explain the way these images could have captions that describe the feeling (i.e. “I feel like this rock: weighed down and heavy.”) Invite students to write a caption to go along with their chosen image or images.

    Example of What You Could Say:

    “I found a few objects that I think show the way I felt when________ (refer to the story that you shared with the class or the way you feel today). Here is one of the photographs I took on our walk. I think it might be interesting if we write captions to our photographs. We don’t need to name the picture. We can simply describe the way the object acts as a metaphor for the way we felt. For instance, I took a photo of a rock because at the time I was feeling weighed down by the things that are bothering me today and heavy in my heart. So I used those two words as my caption: burdened and heavy.”

Wrap-up Activity:

*Slide 4

Upon their return to the classroom, students will work on their captions for their chosen photograph(s). Encourage students to be creative in the way they write their captions and describe the feeling. In this activity, students do not use the actual label for an emotion, but actually describe the feeling behind the emotion – the words that describe how they’re feeling.

There are a few ways you can structure a classroom art gallery: 

  1. You could have students put the image on a word document on their laptops and write their caption underneath. Then, you could invite students to circulate the room looking at each other’s work. 
  2. Another option is to have students email you their images and captions for you to project at the front of the room.
  3. A third option is to print the photographs and captions to hang on the classroom wall.  


As always, students are invited to choose whether or not they want to share their creative projects, and one option above may work better than another if students are more interested in sharing their work anonymously.

Lesson Closure:

Conclude the lesson by celebrating the students’ photography. Share what you noticed as you looked at the photographs (i.e. maybe students used nature to represent feelings). No need to be specific or highlight one student in particular, just praise their creativity and bravery.

Supplemental Information:

If you or your students would like to learn more about the ideas in this lesson, additional resources and third party links are included below.

 

    1. In her book The Vulnerable Heart of Literacy, Elizabeth Dutro illustrates methods for inviting emotion into the classroom. A central theme of this book is the idea that emotion is complex and cannot always be put into words. This book is highly recommended for teachers looking to learn more about the theories and research that inspired this curriculum, and this lesson, in particular.
    2. The artwork of Sally Mann, Willie Middlebrook, Nydaa Blas and Dorthea Lang are great examples of how photographers represent emotion in symbolic or metaphoric ways.
    3. In the intention that introduces this lesson, we cite Patti Lather who quotes the poet Rilke in order to describe some stories as “Too Big” to be put into words. Lather’s essay Drawing the Line at Angels: Working the Ruins of Feminist Ethnography offers greater detail  on her creative work supporting women living with HIV/AIDS as they wrote their stories. The essay can be accessed through an academic article search in a library database.